PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley

The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature review Ü 0 Referring to Lewis Carroll's Red ueen from Through the Looking Glass a character who has to keep running to stay in the same place Matt Ridley demonstrates why sex is humanity's best strategy for outwitting its co. What could have shaped the human mind is an endlessly interesting subject no uestion about that Speculating about contributions of the genes nature nurture culture is fun as much as getting a new perspective on what has always seemed obvious Still I did not like this book as much as I probably would had it a bit less of sheer speculations Some readers praise Ridley for objectively presenting to them so many different and often contradictory theories When discussions are heated it is indeed a virtue But flaws in some of the theories are evident even before the argument is over so why include those if a few paragraphs later Ridley admits that the theory does sound pretty wrong An example attractiveness of slender women nowadays supposedly signalizes their wealth because not every woman can afford a healthy diet Further certain claims are given as well known widely accepted facts while they may not even be true One example is Chomsky s hypotheses about Universal Grammar and language innateness It is far from true that all linguists agree with Chomsky Pinker whom Ridley cites a few times surely does but there are linguists in the world Another example neural networks have recently had a huge comeback researchers have very big hopes for deep learning Obviously Ridley dismissed them as incapable of learning far too early A few times I was wondering where Ridley got his facts from For example describing highly sexed emperors he states that the ancient civilizations we know of were all ruled exclusively by ruthless men with hundreds of wives and thousands of children mostly sons One of his examples is Akhenaten who in fact is known as a loving husband and father of a dozen of children There are numerous depictions of him playing with his daughters Also apparently Ridley never heard of successful female pharaohs His knowledge of the ancient civilizations seems to be based on a cartoon about an evil pharaoh and his poor slavesFinally what annoyed me most is the plasticity of Ridley s evolutionary arguments If there is a trait which he states is characteristic of modern men he simply says that it was obviously advantageous for males in the past Usually he throws in a thought experiment or some bizarre example from the animal world and off to the next section and a new trait But this is not what is needed to prove a hypothesis First the trait may be not as characteristic of men as he wants it to look like For example he says boys are better in math than girls or girls are better in linguistic tasks although even at his time there were studies showing that it very much depends on how boys and girls are treated at elementary school In fact there are countries where girls are better in math Iceland Second for a evolutionary argument to apply there must be a gene so why not name it right away Third why should this particular gene be gender specific why wouldn t it reveal its power in the other gender too Wouldn t men benefit from better language skills something he claims women are better at I doubt so Finally if the gene has not yet been discovered why not show a mathematical model which would at least demonstrate that the benefit of the trait is real and would affect the reproductive success of its carrier What happened with females who were not so elouent Were they and their children killed by better versed women Surely I do see a benefit in being a good talker and I can imagine why this uality could be important for women than men but it still does not explain why this supposedly genetic trait should propagate There is a big difference between soft skills and traits like fear the snakes or lactose tolerance for which reproductive advantage is obvious To summarize an interesting read but with far too many annoying errors logical flaws and sloppy arguments

summary The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human NatureThe Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature review Ü 0 Nstantly mutating internal predators The Red ueen answers dozens of other riddles of human nature and culture including why men propose marriage the method behind our maddening notions of beauty and the disuieting. Well I had hoped to write this review closer to having read the book but I ll write this anyway just without some of the examples I was hoping to rememberRoughly the first 12 to 23 of the books covers the different explanations for why sex arose and the mating habits of various non human species One thing that is great about this book is it will relate a theory then an insufficiency in the theory then a counter theory then additional findings and back and forth and so on If there isn t a consensus it just leaves the uestion open and for you to ponder yourself For anyone interested in how science is done numerous examples ideas blossoming be attacked rediscovered etc are recounted Also lots of different case studies are recounted All the stories of different species behavior is entertaining in and of itselfIn the last part of the book humans are closely examined As long as you repeatedly the disclaimer at the beginning of that section that you may be able to say something about males are X on average and females are Y on average but individual instances of men and women of course may run counter Also that evolution has primed certain tendencies for each sex but tendencies are not fate and thus again you can only talk about averages or generalities If you remember that and don t get your undies in a bunch the discussion of how human nature iswas shaped by evolution is illuminatingSo I recommend this to everyone especially those interested in how the brain works how people work andor how science works

read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley

The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature review Ü 0 Fact that a woman is likely to conceive a child by an adulterous lover than by her husband Brilliantly written The Red ueen offers an extraordinary new way of interpreting the human condition and how it has evolv. Ridley throws a lot of interesting hypotheses at the uestion of why there is sex whyhow we indulge without ever coming to a firm conclusion admitting such I liked that since I didn t find a lot of the studies or statistics he referenced too convincing This is a book with points to ponder rather than a definitive text He writes this at the end of the book Half the ideas in this book are probably wrong The history of human science in this regard is not encouraging But he goes on to uote Hume mention how far we ve progressed since his day We re just not there yet may never be since we re so good at deceiving ourselvesIt s well worth the time to read There are some good insights into why we act the way we do I really liked his opinions on the differences in children of different sexes I ve long been angered by the way the education system treats boys girls the same They re not his point that nurture nature shouldn t be seen as polar opposites but as part of a process was very well madeTable of ContentsPrefaceONE Human NatureTWO The EnigmaTHREE The Power of ParasitesFOUR Genetic Mutiny and GenderFIVE The Peacock s TaleSIX Polygamy and the Nature of MenSEVEN Monogamy and the Nature of WomenEIGHT Sexing the MindNINE The Uses of BeautyTEN The Intellectual Chess GameEPILOGUE The Self domesticated Ape


10 thoughts on “PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

  1. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Things I learned from this book human women like tall men human men like beautiful women barn swallow women like men with long symmetrical tails gentlemen prefer blondes sperm are small because they made a dastardly deal w

  2. says: summary The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Matt Ridley Î 0 summary

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Matt Ridley Î 0 summary Coming out of pre veterinary medicine and a slew of genetics classes I can say that nothing in this book is particularly mind blowing except the hubris The author has drawn up a laundry list of assumptions about all of humanity and le

  3. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Matt Ridley Î 0 summary What could have shaped the human mind is an endlessly interesting subject no uestion about that Speculating about contributions of the genes nature nurture culture is fun as much as getting a new perspective on what has alwa

  4. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Matt Ridley Î 0 summary Well I had hoped to write this review closer to having read the book but I'll write this anyway just without some of the examples I was hoping to rememberRoughly the first 12 to 23 of the books covers the differ

  5. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley summary The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature This was one of those books that I bought because I was sucked in by the title and the cover Plus I thought hey that's kinda out of my comfort zone I'd like to push myself to read something new and possibly difficult to understandI couldn't m

  6. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Matt Ridley Î 0 summary This is really well written but I just can't really wrap my head around the themes of sexuality in this book especially as it concerns the idea of gender Also I don't really trust men of science who can write things like boys are better in mat

  7. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Matt Ridley Î 0 summary summary The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature I enjoyed this book and recommend it highly Some may see it as a cynical view of human nature however I found it to be an engaging and convincing one  My favorite uote from this book sums up the totality of the text for me the choosiness in human beings in picking their mates has driven the human mind into a frenzied expansion for no reason except that wit virtuosityinventiveness and individuality turn people on It is a somewhat less u

  8. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    summary The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley Matt Ridley Î 0 summary How much generous it would be if instead of writing parables about childhood wounds psychologists were to accept that some differences between the sexes just are that they are in the nature of the beasts because each sex h

  9. says: PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature Ridley throws a lot of interesting hypotheses at the uestion of why there is sex whyhow we indulge without ever

  10. says: read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley PDF The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

    read ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Î Matt Ridley Matt Ridley Î 0 summary summary The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature I might have rated this highly if I hadn't just come off a spate of reading very similar and slightly better works that incorporate much of its content in pithier form Daniel Dennett's Darwin's Dangerous Idea and Steven Pinker's How the Mind Works though those were both written afterwards yet its central metaphor of sex

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Paperback
  • 405
  • The Red ueen Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature
  • Matt Ridley
  • English
  • 12 April 2018
  • 9780060556570